Subscriber Ben with a snarky email for me. How dare he.
Hey Ethan,
I noticed there were a couple womens sports commercials during the Super Bowl and wanted to make sure you were okay (winking emoji).
Kidding aside, if you do write about this I’d be super curious to see if you can get any industry people to go on record as to why athletic brands continue to lean into girls and womens sports. There are clearly reasons; those reasons clearly go beyond some amorphous "wokeism."
Cheers,
Ben
Ben’s referring to two ads that made some waves. Nike devoted their lone Super Bowl spot to girl power, and the NFL ran a 1980’s themed flag football commercial wherein a young woman athletically triumphed over some meatheads. One of my main takeaways from the Nike ad was that it’s another instance of the company pretending Caitlin Clark is just one of many spokespeople on roster, rather than a potential billion dollar business unto herself. But that’s a post for another day.
As I said in my inaugural article for this site, there’s a clear business imperative for Nike in pitching women’s sports. Nike has a mostly male customer base, is hungry for growth, and thus is enticed by the Undecided Whale of female market share. Sure they’ve been dominant with boys and men, but what if they somehow woo the demographic that accounts for even more clothing purchases in the United States? That’s the business-minded idea, anyway.
I don’t think that currently struggling Nike is going about their strategy in the right way, which I’ll get into. The same could be said for the NFL’s girl boss-infused flag football ad. Both mega corporations are producing content that seems more fit for 2019, and such messaging didn’t even really work back then. My observation about what’s missing is simple, but the sort of people who produce ads are less liable to channel simplicity. I’m arguing for the sort of family-based sentimentality you’d get from Don Draper’s “Carousel Speech.” I got this epiphany, if you can really call it that, on Super Bowl Sunday, about a couple hours before seeing these commercials…
On Sunday I took my son to a local school playground so he could burn off some energy with his friends. We were there a little early and had some time to kill, so I strolled over to the basketball court. There, I saw my neighbor, a dad around my age, shooting hoops with his daughter. My neighbor is a friendly guy, but usually not outwardly effusive. Here, though, he was beaming. It was about as wholesome a scene as you could conjure as dad and daughter laughed their way through a casual practice session.
It’s basketball season and a couple years in, it’s really clicking for her. I talked with dad about how it’s going and he couldn’t have been happier. In the beginning, when kids are really young, the games are pure chaos. Now, it’s becoming a real sport, and his daughter is loving it. There’s a lot of cultural focus on not going too far as a sports parent, so much so that the positives might be a little underrated. Even if your kid isn’t destined for D1, there’s a particular joy in seeing them grow up out there. You’re witnessing and processing their physical emergence in a way you don’t quite get when they’re on your couch. Like much of parenting, it’s simultaneously mundane and incredible.
I’m curious about all this because my son is starting out with basketball and I’m wondering about how a kid progresses. I also like getting a sense of life from that Father of Daughters perspective, since I have sons. It’s a different experience from mine, but not completely.
From what I can tell, similar to how I’m more involved with pushing my son on the sports front, fathers are generally more involved with their daughters in athletics. I’m sure you could tell me of counter examples, but I’m talking generally. The experience of Caitlin Clark’s dad having been the primary force behind her basketball involvement is more typical than unique. The sports dad connection is shared by million of girls around the nation and it’s often an emotional one. I’m reminded of Wright Thompson’s Caitlin Clark profile, specifically the section about the aftermath of her loss to LSU.
She kept it together until she saw her father.
He waited for her in the lobby.
She burst into tears and buried her head in his shoulder.
"You have so much to be proud of," he told her.
"I know but still it's sad, Dad," she said.
That’s a scene you can imagine happening at the height of competition, or just after a high school game in some random town. It’s real. Perhaps Nike could highlight the parental connection to future greatness, as they did with Tiger Woods.
Instead, Nike is continuing with some artificial campaign against our culture’s supposed conspiracy against women’s sports. Their slogan is, “Whatever you do, you can't win. So win.” It’s discordant for multiple reasons, including the lack of clarity on what’s being argued. Also, bringing up the idea that “women can’t win,” might remind people of that whole uncomfortable saga of males having entered into women’s sports. Maybe I should be a little more deferential to the professional ad makers in all their expertise, but the last time I questioned their marketing methods, Nike’s stock price was a lot higher.
I feel similarly about the NFL’s lighter flag football spot. Commissioner Roger Goodell has some grand gambit to get girls playing flag football, and well, maybe? Perhaps there’s an Undecided Whale of little girls hoping to join a version of America’s most popular sport that doesn’t break sternums.
The ad, much mocked in conservative leaning spaces, depicts a scene where a young woman can humiliate archetypal high school jocks on the gridiron by playing this version of the game. Of course it’s a fantasy, shared to what degree who knows. I think the idea is that flag football, devoid of brutal physicality, evens the playing field between the sexes.
Of course it doesn’t quite work that way, and I doubt this sales pitch is all that charismatic. Sure you’re selling aspiration and aspiration can be unrealistic, but at least maybe try to have a patina of authenticity?
It might make more sense to have an ad where a father mourns his lost football playing past, only to find a new joy in his daughter’s flag football emergence. That could be fun and funny. You could even lightly mock the classic Al Bundy self glorification of one’s high school past. It’s at least a commercial actually oriented towards the person most likely to do the sign ups and buy the gear.
The general ideas discussed in this post aren’t revolutionary. Indeed, they’re the opposite of revolutionary: Focus on family, focus on wholesome. It just so happens that, in the culture of Art School oriented types who often write such pitches, the mundane is revolutionary. What, we’re not subverting the entire social order today? We’re just selling products to people who might want them? Is this even legal?
It is indeed legal, though. You’re allowed to just make ads that emotionally connect with the likely customer. Perhaps my ideas aren’t appealing to ad makers because it runs contra to a certain worldview where women don’t need others to succeed. But women, being people, are connected to others. We’ve known for awhile that No Man Is An Island. Perhaps it’s time for Nike and other sports giants to understand that no woman is either.



The thing is, most people, even "conservatives", don't hate women's sports. Even "conservatives" have daughters, sisters, nieces, cousins, friends who play sports. And everyone has been steeped in rooting for women in the Olympics, etc. The vast majority of people are not predisposed to hate womens sports. The default is that most people will ignore women's sports (because we ignore 95% of things in the world) and periodically engage with something that interests them..
What people don't abide by is
1) being an asshole and telling me I'm an enemy (Nike, WNBA, USWNT)
2) peddling ridiculous bullshit (NFL, thousands of TV shows, movies etc.)
Don't imply to the audience that we are the problem and we're holding you down. Don't tell us that girls are way better at sports than guys. This is an audience that likes sports - it should be easy to find a message that resonates - hard work, thrill of victory/agony of defeat, family community. It shouldn't be that hard.
The Nike Super Bowl ad reminded me of that embarrassing Barbie monologue - a bunch of self-victimizing, woe-is-me nonsense that's years, if not decades, behind the times ("You can't be confident"? What? Who is telling women that, in 2025?), interspersed with laments about how society just won't let you be an inconsiderate, self-absorbed person. "You can't be demanding, you can't put yourself first..." I mean, yeah, most people don't like other people, male or female, who are notably demanding and constantly put themselves first. That's just... basic life skills. Bizarre stuff.
"Whatever you do, you can't win" is such a pathetic - and blatantly false - message to give people.