The thing is, most people, even "conservatives", don't hate women's sports. Even "conservatives" have daughters, sisters, nieces, cousins, friends who play sports. And everyone has been steeped in rooting for women in the Olympics, etc. The vast majority of people are not predisposed to hate womens sports. The default is that most people will ignore women's sports (because we ignore 95% of things in the world) and periodically engage with something that interests them..
What people don't abide by is
1) being an asshole and telling me I'm an enemy (Nike, WNBA, USWNT)
2) peddling ridiculous bullshit (NFL, thousands of TV shows, movies etc.)
Don't imply to the audience that we are the problem and we're holding you down. Don't tell us that girls are way better at sports than guys. This is an audience that likes sports - it should be easy to find a message that resonates - hard work, thrill of victory/agony of defeat, family community. It shouldn't be that hard.
Well women's sports got off to a bad foot because its rollout was pretty forced and adversarial.
In the 90s at least in my area you suddenly had Title IX enforcement where universities were shutting down very successful and storied men's programs (wrestling comes to mind) to set up women's programs there was little interest in.
So you had a student body with 5000 men and 5000 women, 3000 of the men would love an athletic scholarship and were interested in one, and 200 women. I know what fairness is, lets hand out 150 scholarships for men and 150 for women! Also we can only afford 20 sports programs and before it was 18:2 men. Of course that reflected the natural proportion of interest, but we better bring that figure to 10:10 to be safe.
At the youth level our city based organization at some point in the mid 90s decide to end co-ed and set up separate programs and split the budget 50/50. There were maybe say 2500 boys players and 90 girls...but equal budgets, which means the girls got the best of everything. Great for them I guess, but as you might imagine...there was a lot of resentment and hard feelings for a few years (I want to say even before 2000 they backed off this policy as it was causing too much friction).
I do think dads are honestly like half of what drives women's sports. All the biggest women's sports advocates/coaches I know are men who were athletes who only had daughters. It is SUPER common. There are of course others, but I personally know 5 dudes super into women's sports, all are dads with only daughters.
I know some other dads with kids of both sexes, and they might help a bit, but they aren't all about women's sports.
Anyway, I agree there was no real golden age. It has been contentious the whole time because it was never really organic, always forced.
We had a girl who was the ~170th best player in our program in my era, a program that might produce 1 college scholarship for every 250 boys, get a full ride to Harvard and she won a national championship there. So literally you might have across 5 years, 250 boy players and 15 girls. The girls might be ranked at best in the top of the bottom quartile of players.
And the single very best guy would get a scholarship, and 5 of the girls. So say players 1 (boy), 170 (girl), 190 (girl), 200 (girl), 225 (girl), and 230 (girl) would get scholarships to play sports out of 250.
You can imagine how the boys in say positions 2-20 felt about that. It became A LOT less glaring once they got rid of all the co-ed play and so it was more out of sight out of mind.
The Nike Super Bowl ad reminded me of that embarrassing Barbie monologue - a bunch of self-victimizing, woe-is-me nonsense that's years, if not decades, behind the times ("You can't be confident"? What? Who is telling women that, in 2025?), interspersed with laments about how society just won't let you be an inconsiderate, self-absorbed person. "You can't be demanding, you can't put yourself first..." I mean, yeah, most people don't like other people, male or female, who are notably demanding and constantly put themselves first. That's just... basic life skills. Bizarre stuff.
"Whatever you do, you can't win" is such a pathetic - and blatantly false - message to give people.
You could populate a city with all the strawmen in Barbie, a movie set in a world that looks like the 2020s but has the gender and sexual politics of the late 60s and 70s.
When watching Super Bowl ads it’s always a challenge to determine how much can be explained by the marketing people being stupid, how much by marketing people believing that the target audience is stupid, and how much by stupid marketing people believing the audience is stupid.
Hopefully linking to myself isn't against the rules, but I wrote about the Nike ad and referenced "Nike's End of Men." I am way more political than the host here, but I also have a daughter who's played soccer since she was 4. She's now 15. She doesn't pretend her club can beat a boys' club, but she also constantly talks trash about how the boys flop more, etc. She doesn't see it as a gender war in the way that older generations do. Boys are stronger, so what, she and her teammates are doing their thing and competing against comparable opponents. What I didn't get into in this piece is how it's not just ad people trying to impress one another, but in terms of chasing the Undecided Whales, Nike's agency, a la Gerwig's "Barbie," got caught up in appealing mainly to Gen X women who grew up more immersed in the gender wars. As we Gen Xers are getting old, we're losing touch with what actually animates younger generations and how they're influenced and it shows.
My hope is that younger generation rebel against the dumbest parts of their parents' generation (commoditizing victimhood, negative energy around the war of sexes and hating men, body positivity over unhealthy morbid obesity yet celebrating teaching toddlers it's OK to hate your genitals, the juxtaposition of pride combined with heavy amounts self-consciousness and botox).
In relation to your article, Anson Frericks , a former Budweiser executive, wrote a book about the whole Dylan Mulvaney Bud Light debacle. Here is a link to an excerpt:
I thought the Nike ad was great. All of the athletes happened to be women, but it wasn't a "women's" ad. You could've subbed in any collection of Nike athletes and it still would've worked. It's a pretty standard Nike ad: the athletes are treated like badasses and the central conceit of the ad is basically "just do it."
Especially in basketball, Nike has collapsed some of the distance between their mens and womens stuff anyways—Sabrina Ionescu's signature shoes are hugely popular with men and women; A'ja Wilson and, eventually, Caitlin Clark will also definitely have unisex lines.
Nike has incredible female athletes and is clearly approaching their marketing the same way that they approach marketing their male stars so as not to alienate male consumers. The average man would be a lot more likely to buy Caitlin Clark shoes if she's treated like Kobe or Lebron than if the ad is about how she has the best girl-dad in the whole wide world.
"The average man would be a lot more likely to buy Caitlin Clark shoes if she's treated like Kobe or Lebron than if the ad is about how she has the best girl-dad in the whole wide world."
This is a great point. I didn't know that popular unisex lines of shoes were a thing, but this makes sense. Thing is, if they want to expand into the niche of competitive athlete females it seems like what they are doing is an OK move and it won't alienate too many men. But that's a pretty small niche. But if they want to expand to the majority of females without losing their male audience they basically need to make a "sister" brand, imo.
All the men's shoes have been unisex for years—WNBA players wear the same shoes as NBA players, just in women's sizes. The Sabrina line was unique in that it was the first time a Nike made a unisex line for one of their female athletes and it was a huge success—a good shoe will appeal to everyone. I play a lot of basketball and have a bunch of shoes and Sabrina Ionescu's newest sneakers are my favorite.
At least for shoes, I don't think a sister brand is necessary because it's just needlessly pushing away potential costumers. With performance shoes, they can and should be gender neutral because they already come in men's vs women's sizing—it's not like only men need good traction and only women need good support. Everyone is buying the same shoes at the end of the day, so it makes sense to market your shoes so that everyone wants to buy them.
I just find it disconcerting how large men loom in ads about women’s sports. When I watch ads featuring Messi, Mbappe, Lebron, Ohtani, ect. women aren’t referenced at all. And why would they be? And yet, the NFL seems to think the only way to make a sport enticing to women is to dangle out the promise of beating the patriarchy. Same vibes with the Nike ad. IMO if a given woman cares deeply about being better than men— wouldn’t she want to go into anything *other* than sports? It seems like an especially egalitarian minded young woman would be more likely to be drawn to interests where men don’t have an innate advantage. Those ads I mentioned earlier featuring male athletes focus on themes like hard work, dedication, and persistence. What ad executive decided that those themes wouldn’t resonate with a female audience as well? My tldr is just why do womens sports ads have to talk about men at all— can’t they, you know, talk about women?
Really good article and I agree that the proposed girl dad type commercial would be well received.
The flag football ad was derivative on a few levels. It reminds us of other commercials referencing the brilliant athletic accomplishments of men. There was an Air Jordan commercial years back where young kids and teenagers performed Mike's moves and mannerisms in different settings as the music swelled. Later there was some (Gatorade? Foot Locker?) commercial spot that ran for the entire playoffs that depicted a coed game where a woman crossed over a man and stepped over him ala Allen Iverson. Many such examples.
The irksome bit for me was the girl doing the Saquon reverse hurdle, which was one of the more stunning athletic moments of the last five years. Had this visual joke been a part of a breezy montage of an all women game, or even some rock and jock mixed gender BBQ picnic like we've seen a million times, fine.
However, for culture war reasons women's flag football is somehow being framed as a blow against the patriarchy and it comes off like stolen valor when ad execs take a brilliant masculine achievement that we all remember and pretend as if a woman could perform it to defeat a man as we all watch The Super Bowl. It forces men to silently think sexist thoughts that would never occur to us otherwise. I wondered for the first time in my sports obsessed life if a woman has ever in history done something that was generative or unique like Barkley that we hadn't already seen before.
Men weren't thinking about whether they could beat up Ronda Rousey, women journalists spent five years saying she'd beat Mayweather. Men were fine with vaguely appreciating Serena Williams, women journalists kept forcing her into conversations about Jordan and Tiger and Brady. This is counter-productive and annoying.
How should Nike market Caitlin Clark? She should obviously feature in her own commercials, but since that seems unpalatable to her subsidized basketball league, I would go back to basics. Get all the WNBA "stars" in a gym and do a take on The Second Coming ad. Let basketball sell basketball.
While Nike goes after the "whale" that is women's merchandise sales, its losing men. Nike stock broke through 70 yesterday for a short period of time, the low from March of 20 when covid fears were highest. Its amazing how shortsighted they are.
I am kicking myself for not shorting Nike around the time you launched HoS with ‘Nike’s End of Men’. The stock is down ~60% from its peak in late 2021 after seemingly being resistant to a “woke backlash”. I even recall Ethan musing that its market dominance might make it too big to fail. It’s clearly not the case now. IMO, strategic distribution changes aside, It just took a couple consumer purchasing cycles while doubling-down on progressive messaging for Nike’s fading brand to yield serious consequences.
This latest ad signals its appeal will continue to deteriorate without much abatement. Purchasing medium term puts today.
"Maybe I should be a little more deferential to the professional ad makers in all their expertise, but the last time I questioned their marketing methods, Nike’s stock price was a lot higher."
It’s quite fragmented now, you’ve got the likes of vuori, alo and many others, lot of women in my work in their 20s wear new balance which I find a bit mad as I seem them as dad shoes
The "Father of Daughters perspective" you're referring to is the idea of Girl Dads, which I would argue is a pretty mainstream concept and target audience for sports marketers since since Elle Duncan popularized the term five years ago with her Kobe story. I can think of multiple pro sports teams who have targeted the "girl dad" with ticket packages, theme nights and other promotions. And I agree! It's definitely a compelling idea - dads and daughters having common ground to bond over - but one I do feel is well-trodden territory for brands. So I don't think it's a miss on Nike's part to go in a different creative direction.
The ad felt very Nike to me, riffing on the "just do it" mantra (<--- speaking of a lack of clarity!) with the "just win" tagline. And Nike flexed their roster of athletes, many of whom are known by name or appearance to casual sports fans watching.
The thing is, most people, even "conservatives", don't hate women's sports. Even "conservatives" have daughters, sisters, nieces, cousins, friends who play sports. And everyone has been steeped in rooting for women in the Olympics, etc. The vast majority of people are not predisposed to hate womens sports. The default is that most people will ignore women's sports (because we ignore 95% of things in the world) and periodically engage with something that interests them..
What people don't abide by is
1) being an asshole and telling me I'm an enemy (Nike, WNBA, USWNT)
2) peddling ridiculous bullshit (NFL, thousands of TV shows, movies etc.)
Don't imply to the audience that we are the problem and we're holding you down. Don't tell us that girls are way better at sports than guys. This is an audience that likes sports - it should be easy to find a message that resonates - hard work, thrill of victory/agony of defeat, family community. It shouldn't be that hard.
I mean when was this golden time before women's sports were not woke and ratings and interest were higher than they were before?
Well women's sports got off to a bad foot because its rollout was pretty forced and adversarial.
In the 90s at least in my area you suddenly had Title IX enforcement where universities were shutting down very successful and storied men's programs (wrestling comes to mind) to set up women's programs there was little interest in.
So you had a student body with 5000 men and 5000 women, 3000 of the men would love an athletic scholarship and were interested in one, and 200 women. I know what fairness is, lets hand out 150 scholarships for men and 150 for women! Also we can only afford 20 sports programs and before it was 18:2 men. Of course that reflected the natural proportion of interest, but we better bring that figure to 10:10 to be safe.
At the youth level our city based organization at some point in the mid 90s decide to end co-ed and set up separate programs and split the budget 50/50. There were maybe say 2500 boys players and 90 girls...but equal budgets, which means the girls got the best of everything. Great for them I guess, but as you might imagine...there was a lot of resentment and hard feelings for a few years (I want to say even before 2000 they backed off this policy as it was causing too much friction).
I do think dads are honestly like half of what drives women's sports. All the biggest women's sports advocates/coaches I know are men who were athletes who only had daughters. It is SUPER common. There are of course others, but I personally know 5 dudes super into women's sports, all are dads with only daughters.
I know some other dads with kids of both sexes, and they might help a bit, but they aren't all about women's sports.
Anyway, I agree there was no real golden age. It has been contentious the whole time because it was never really organic, always forced.
We had a girl who was the ~170th best player in our program in my era, a program that might produce 1 college scholarship for every 250 boys, get a full ride to Harvard and she won a national championship there. So literally you might have across 5 years, 250 boy players and 15 girls. The girls might be ranked at best in the top of the bottom quartile of players.
And the single very best guy would get a scholarship, and 5 of the girls. So say players 1 (boy), 170 (girl), 190 (girl), 200 (girl), 225 (girl), and 230 (girl) would get scholarships to play sports out of 250.
You can imagine how the boys in say positions 2-20 felt about that. It became A LOT less glaring once they got rid of all the co-ed play and so it was more out of sight out of mind.
Mia Hamm?
The Nike Super Bowl ad reminded me of that embarrassing Barbie monologue - a bunch of self-victimizing, woe-is-me nonsense that's years, if not decades, behind the times ("You can't be confident"? What? Who is telling women that, in 2025?), interspersed with laments about how society just won't let you be an inconsiderate, self-absorbed person. "You can't be demanding, you can't put yourself first..." I mean, yeah, most people don't like other people, male or female, who are notably demanding and constantly put themselves first. That's just... basic life skills. Bizarre stuff.
"Whatever you do, you can't win" is such a pathetic - and blatantly false - message to give people.
You could populate a city with all the strawmen in Barbie, a movie set in a world that looks like the 2020s but has the gender and sexual politics of the late 60s and 70s.
When watching Super Bowl ads it’s always a challenge to determine how much can be explained by the marketing people being stupid, how much by marketing people believing that the target audience is stupid, and how much by stupid marketing people believing the audience is stupid.
That Gillette Super Bowl ad about toxic masculinity when they charged more for the womens equivalent of male products was a highlight
Don't worry, AI will replace all the marketing people soon.
And AI will create commercials with black nazis and Founding Fathers, and female Asian Vikings. Right, Google Gemini?
Hopefully linking to myself isn't against the rules, but I wrote about the Nike ad and referenced "Nike's End of Men." I am way more political than the host here, but I also have a daughter who's played soccer since she was 4. She's now 15. She doesn't pretend her club can beat a boys' club, but she also constantly talks trash about how the boys flop more, etc. She doesn't see it as a gender war in the way that older generations do. Boys are stronger, so what, she and her teammates are doing their thing and competing against comparable opponents. What I didn't get into in this piece is how it's not just ad people trying to impress one another, but in terms of chasing the Undecided Whales, Nike's agency, a la Gerwig's "Barbie," got caught up in appealing mainly to Gen X women who grew up more immersed in the gender wars. As we Gen Xers are getting old, we're losing touch with what actually animates younger generations and how they're influenced and it shows.
https://thefederalist.com/2025/02/11/next-time-nike-is-tempted-to-run-a-feminist-super-bowl-ad-just-dont-do-it/
My hope is that younger generation rebel against the dumbest parts of their parents' generation (commoditizing victimhood, negative energy around the war of sexes and hating men, body positivity over unhealthy morbid obesity yet celebrating teaching toddlers it's OK to hate your genitals, the juxtaposition of pride combined with heavy amounts self-consciousness and botox).
In relation to your article, Anson Frericks , a former Budweiser executive, wrote a book about the whole Dylan Mulvaney Bud Light debacle. Here is a link to an excerpt:
https://archive.ph/F5xAe
I thought the Nike ad was great. All of the athletes happened to be women, but it wasn't a "women's" ad. You could've subbed in any collection of Nike athletes and it still would've worked. It's a pretty standard Nike ad: the athletes are treated like badasses and the central conceit of the ad is basically "just do it."
Especially in basketball, Nike has collapsed some of the distance between their mens and womens stuff anyways—Sabrina Ionescu's signature shoes are hugely popular with men and women; A'ja Wilson and, eventually, Caitlin Clark will also definitely have unisex lines.
Nike has incredible female athletes and is clearly approaching their marketing the same way that they approach marketing their male stars so as not to alienate male consumers. The average man would be a lot more likely to buy Caitlin Clark shoes if she's treated like Kobe or Lebron than if the ad is about how she has the best girl-dad in the whole wide world.
"The average man would be a lot more likely to buy Caitlin Clark shoes if she's treated like Kobe or Lebron than if the ad is about how she has the best girl-dad in the whole wide world."
This is a great point. I didn't know that popular unisex lines of shoes were a thing, but this makes sense. Thing is, if they want to expand into the niche of competitive athlete females it seems like what they are doing is an OK move and it won't alienate too many men. But that's a pretty small niche. But if they want to expand to the majority of females without losing their male audience they basically need to make a "sister" brand, imo.
All the men's shoes have been unisex for years—WNBA players wear the same shoes as NBA players, just in women's sizes. The Sabrina line was unique in that it was the first time a Nike made a unisex line for one of their female athletes and it was a huge success—a good shoe will appeal to everyone. I play a lot of basketball and have a bunch of shoes and Sabrina Ionescu's newest sneakers are my favorite.
At least for shoes, I don't think a sister brand is necessary because it's just needlessly pushing away potential costumers. With performance shoes, they can and should be gender neutral because they already come in men's vs women's sizing—it's not like only men need good traction and only women need good support. Everyone is buying the same shoes at the end of the day, so it makes sense to market your shoes so that everyone wants to buy them.
"Whatever you do, you can't win, so win" doesn't exactly roll off the tongue like "Just do it"
I just find it disconcerting how large men loom in ads about women’s sports. When I watch ads featuring Messi, Mbappe, Lebron, Ohtani, ect. women aren’t referenced at all. And why would they be? And yet, the NFL seems to think the only way to make a sport enticing to women is to dangle out the promise of beating the patriarchy. Same vibes with the Nike ad. IMO if a given woman cares deeply about being better than men— wouldn’t she want to go into anything *other* than sports? It seems like an especially egalitarian minded young woman would be more likely to be drawn to interests where men don’t have an innate advantage. Those ads I mentioned earlier featuring male athletes focus on themes like hard work, dedication, and persistence. What ad executive decided that those themes wouldn’t resonate with a female audience as well? My tldr is just why do womens sports ads have to talk about men at all— can’t they, you know, talk about women?
Really good article and I agree that the proposed girl dad type commercial would be well received.
The flag football ad was derivative on a few levels. It reminds us of other commercials referencing the brilliant athletic accomplishments of men. There was an Air Jordan commercial years back where young kids and teenagers performed Mike's moves and mannerisms in different settings as the music swelled. Later there was some (Gatorade? Foot Locker?) commercial spot that ran for the entire playoffs that depicted a coed game where a woman crossed over a man and stepped over him ala Allen Iverson. Many such examples.
The irksome bit for me was the girl doing the Saquon reverse hurdle, which was one of the more stunning athletic moments of the last five years. Had this visual joke been a part of a breezy montage of an all women game, or even some rock and jock mixed gender BBQ picnic like we've seen a million times, fine.
However, for culture war reasons women's flag football is somehow being framed as a blow against the patriarchy and it comes off like stolen valor when ad execs take a brilliant masculine achievement that we all remember and pretend as if a woman could perform it to defeat a man as we all watch The Super Bowl. It forces men to silently think sexist thoughts that would never occur to us otherwise. I wondered for the first time in my sports obsessed life if a woman has ever in history done something that was generative or unique like Barkley that we hadn't already seen before.
Men weren't thinking about whether they could beat up Ronda Rousey, women journalists spent five years saying she'd beat Mayweather. Men were fine with vaguely appreciating Serena Williams, women journalists kept forcing her into conversations about Jordan and Tiger and Brady. This is counter-productive and annoying.
How should Nike market Caitlin Clark? She should obviously feature in her own commercials, but since that seems unpalatable to her subsidized basketball league, I would go back to basics. Get all the WNBA "stars" in a gym and do a take on The Second Coming ad. Let basketball sell basketball.
https://youtu.be/3iEay9CBP5g?si=f2vf5SRAaFJe7Jlu
While Nike goes after the "whale" that is women's merchandise sales, its losing men. Nike stock broke through 70 yesterday for a short period of time, the low from March of 20 when covid fears were highest. Its amazing how shortsighted they are.
I am kicking myself for not shorting Nike around the time you launched HoS with ‘Nike’s End of Men’. The stock is down ~60% from its peak in late 2021 after seemingly being resistant to a “woke backlash”. I even recall Ethan musing that its market dominance might make it too big to fail. It’s clearly not the case now. IMO, strategic distribution changes aside, It just took a couple consumer purchasing cycles while doubling-down on progressive messaging for Nike’s fading brand to yield serious consequences.
This latest ad signals its appeal will continue to deteriorate without much abatement. Purchasing medium term puts today.
"Maybe I should be a little more deferential to the professional ad makers in all their expertise, but the last time I questioned their marketing methods, Nike’s stock price was a lot higher."
Banger
Nice piece, Ethan. I think Nike is the best muse for House of Strauss.
I watched the flag football ad with an eleven year old girl and she was like “oh man that would be awesome I would love to play flag football.”
Kinda makes sense for the nfl?
Isn't this as simple as Lululemon has women athleisure cornered, it would be nice to get some of that money?
It’s quite fragmented now, you’ve got the likes of vuori, alo and many others, lot of women in my work in their 20s wear new balance which I find a bit mad as I seem them as dad shoes
The "Father of Daughters perspective" you're referring to is the idea of Girl Dads, which I would argue is a pretty mainstream concept and target audience for sports marketers since since Elle Duncan popularized the term five years ago with her Kobe story. I can think of multiple pro sports teams who have targeted the "girl dad" with ticket packages, theme nights and other promotions. And I agree! It's definitely a compelling idea - dads and daughters having common ground to bond over - but one I do feel is well-trodden territory for brands. So I don't think it's a miss on Nike's part to go in a different creative direction.
The ad felt very Nike to me, riffing on the "just do it" mantra (<--- speaking of a lack of clarity!) with the "just win" tagline. And Nike flexed their roster of athletes, many of whom are known by name or appearance to casual sports fans watching.
So Ethan, when are you dropping the new pod with Freddie DeBoer? I assume you can't resist discussing his hot take on Patrick Mahomes.
https://tinyurl.com/2sru8ats
I love that he wrote it. Might write about it.