It’s hard to answer unasked questions for the same reason it’s difficult to hit a target without aiming. With that in mind, there’s a common disagreement on the Nike topic. Some believe the company collapsed only due to a failed retail strategy. Me? Even though I agree this was the primary cause I also believe a) A company culture that’s become ridiculous is more likely to make tangible strategic errors and b) A company inordinately reliant on cultural cachet can destroy its value proposition with comically bad marketing.
I’ll be frank. I think some media people are disinclined to see what’s clear about Nike’s fall because they regard an Outkick-style, “COMPANY GOES WOKE, GOES BROKE” appraisal to be low status. It’s higher status to say, “Well you see, Nike’s aggressive push into DTC sales ceded retail space to challengers while eroding margin advantage and…” And hey it’s all true, uncontestable, but also importantly: Uncontroversial. But if you start making judgments like, “Gee, the company got a little too invested in pushing Tumblr feminism on a massive scale,” you’re going to catch some flak. Media peers might suspect you’re the wrong kind of person. And so I believe that, in some media spaces, there’s a bias against getting real here.
Relatedly, there’s also a prevailing bias, showcased at Nike’s Investor Day, against asking the following basic question about the shoe company’s disproportionately male consumer base: What do men want?
You don’t talk about such low status concerns in prestige media. When I was at The Athletic, an experience I quite enjoyed by the way, we would have these meetings where our readership demographics got presented like it was a problem. The observation that our customer base was overwhelmingly male never came with an attached, “So what can we do to appeal to males?” It was always, in my recollection, brought up to suggest a deficiency. It was either an indicator that we weren’t doing well enough with women, or that, hey, there’s so much growth potential with women.
What Women Want
Back in the year 2000, there was a forgettable romcom called What Women Want. Or, if it wasn’t forgettable, it’s perhaps best remembered as the movie where Mel Gibson gives Marisa Tomei an orgasm through the aid of secret telepathy. “Mel Gibson gains the ability to read female minds and experiences growth” sounds like the plot of a mediocre bomb. The movie was indeed not very good, it’s hardly referenced today, but it happened to make an immense $374.1 million at the millennium’s turn.
You see, back then, the idea of female mysteriousness was plausible, even if telepathy wasn’t. There was no social media. Beyond conversation and anecdotes, the only means a man had for understanding the female mind was through mass media. In the 1990s, that was a product primarily produced by fellow males. Thus the plot made “sense,” even if it was absurd. Today it’s men, prone to anti-social reticence in the social media age, who are the culture’s black box.


