Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Allan's avatar

"The favored academic perspective is to be a moral absolutist across time, but relativist across space."

That's so well said that it kinda makes me angry I didn't say it first.

Expand full comment
Joseph Conner Micallef's avatar

As always the Columbus take is spot-on. I get SO annoyed by the group of people that play the whole “Columbus didn’t discover anything” card. For the average Old Worlder Columbus discovered the New World and for the average New Worlder he discovered the Old. It’s like saying an Alien landing isn’t impressive because humans were already on Earth.

And on land acknowledgements: my biggest annoyance with them is how empty (and frankly insulting) they are. Cities like Seattle and San Francisco spend SO much energy saying that they stole the land and that it belongs to tribes, but what exactly do they do to show it? Do the tribes get special access? Land returned? Nope. They get shit. You put a sign in front of a university foodbank saying that it’s rightful property of some tribe and one of the tribal members comes in and asks for food you say it’s not for them. It’s an apology without the make-good that’s fundamental to an apology. It’s like stealing somebody’s phone, apologizing while waving it in their face, and when they ask for their phone back you just tell them no.

Expand full comment
70 more comments...

No posts