Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joseph Conner Micallef's avatar

The NBA-NFL divide is a perfect allegory for the country as a whole. The NBA is cool, it’s hip, it’s the future, it’s WAY bigger on social media, and it’s getting absolutely crushed by the NFL. The NBA may be mostly black players but it’s the sport of my people and Twitter’s population - social science college graduates. The league will eventually learn that catering SO heavily to this small population at the expense of the wider public is terrible business, but for now the NBA just gets think-pieces from people like me on how it’s the future of sports and entertainment while its ratings tank and the NFL - the “boomer league” - just keeps printing money.

Expand full comment
Jay Ratkowski's avatar

You could make a good argument about the relative importance of each regular season game for the NBA vs NFL and come to some valid conclusions about why opening day ratings aren't a fair comparison.

And you could maybe make the point that the NFL, like baseball, has ratings carried by old people who aren't NBA fans. And advertisers (the ones paying for the massive TV contracts which fuel the leagues) don't care about old people.

Cool. So what if we look at the Super Bowl vs NBA Finals? And only for the key demo (18-49 year olds). Yeah, the Super Bowl is more of an event itself that appeals beyond the sports fan... but it should be close, right?

In 2021, the Super Bowl nabbed 34.3 million viewers in the key demo. Which is a huge decline from a decade ago when it was routinely in the 50 million range.

The 2021 NBA Finals? The clinching game 6 brought in a peak of 16.6 million TOTAL viewers.

Ouch.

The NBA is harder to watch in ways that the ratings folks count. The regional sports networks that show most local games require expensive and archaic cable packages in most markets. The "national" games are still largely on cable tv. I'd love to know what percentage of fans illegally stream games. But regardless, that has to lead to lesser interest by the time we hit the later rounds of the playoffs. At least to some degree.

Still I'll agree the embrace of spectacle over sport (I'm taking "twitterization" to be a metaphor for that) has to be at least a decent share of the issue.

Fans, especially more conservative white fans who make up close to half the country and an even greater share of the TV audience, get fairly stereotyped for complaining about aesthetics or distractions from the game. Too much complaining, too much showboating, too much flopping, too much traveling (never try to explain the two step rule to the 63 year old guy behind you who is wearing a football jersey to an NBA game and is four $11 beers into the night).

I don't want to try and guess what amount of that is code for people not liking the antics of African American athletes. I'm sure it's a big number. But still, the NFL put a stop to elaborate endzone dances. Offsides and false start penalties limit how much time a player can spend complaining about a call. And a travel just seems to get way more negative energy than a holding call that is missed. Point being, out of structure of the game and intentional changes - the NFL shuts down a lot of the stuff the angry old drunk guy behind you might complain about.

The NBA? They turn it into youtube clips. They've gotten way better about policing flopping and excessive fighting with refs. But people still see James Harden play basketball. Nothing has been fixed.

And you're dead on that the spectacle just gets worse when you're away from the court. 20% of the screen being taken up by "Kyrie Irving Vaccination Status" is absurd. This isn't breaking news about a terrorist attack. And maybe the NBA media should consider how their largely black audience feels considering black male americans have among the lowest vaccination rates for any group. The NBA, teams and cities can push players to get vaccinated. The media? Stay out. Maybe demonizing players over an issue that a lot of fans can relate to is a bad move.

Last thing I'll say is, the Last Dance was eye opening for a ton of casual basketball fans. Michael Jordan was/is a god among athletes and celebrities. But maybe a lot of that status is because in the 80s/90s all we saw were the dunks, the steals, the smile. You had to be plugged into the newspaper gossip to know about the gambling and the tormenting of teammates. Maybe if Jordan was born 30 years later and was an avid social media user, we would really hate what we saw. And if he stayed off social media, the way a small handful of stars do? We probably would also like him less. Why won't he open up to us?

I think Bill Simmons had a line way back about how if you actually got to know a lot of the people you idolize, you really wouldn't like them. I can attest from my own experiences that he's probably dead on. But no matter how carefully curated the tweets or IG posts are, we're all forced into getting to know the NBA players in a way that no other sport emphasizes. And I'm certain there are plenty of good dudes in the NBA. That doesn't mean we actually want to be friends with them.

Expand full comment
28 more comments...

No posts